1. ) DATIN PADUKA DR. TAN YEE KEW 2. ) VIJAYA KUMARI A/P KANNIPAN 3. ) LEE CHUN TACK 4. ) RAZALI BIN ABU BAKAR 5. ) ASMUNI BIN NAFIAH 6. ) DEWI MURNI HARUN 7. ) VASANDA A/P VYTHILIGAM 8. ) MOHAMED NOORSYAFIQ BIN SHAMSUDIN 9. ) THULOSIMANY 10. ) SABRINA BINTI SAHUL HAMID 11. ) KALADEVI A/P RAMACHANTHIRAN 12. ) VELLAMMAL A/P VADAMALAY 13. ) RAJA NORSIDAH BT RAJA ABDUL JALIL 14. ) SITI NORWANA BINTI ZAKARIA 15. ) NUR AFIQAH BINIL MOHTAR APANDI 16. ) TAMIL SELVI A/P SUBRAMANIAM 17. ) MUNIAMAH A/P...
Catchwords
This judgment dismisses a tort action by 810 plaintiffs against 18 defendants arising from a September 2020 water disruption in Wangsa Maju, Kuala Lumpur. The High Court determined the threshold issue of locus standi after the first plaintiff (PW-1), a former Member of Parliament, testified as sole witness. The Court held this was a private law tort action requiring strict standing requirements, not public interest litigation. PW-1 lacked personal standing, having resided outside the affected area with no personal water disruption. The action failed as a representative proceeding under Order 15 Rule 12 ROC 2012, lacked endorsement under Order 6 Rule 2(1)(b) and proper authorization. The remaining 809 plaintiffs adduced no evidence and defects emerged where 103 plaintiffs with non-existent identity card numbers, 8 deceased plaintiffs, 3 undischarged bankrupts without DGI sanction, and 8 residing outside the affected area. PW-1 admitted inability to prove any claim and lacked written authorisation from the plaintiffs. Locus standi; representative action; tort; private law standing; Order 15 Rule 12; Order 6 Rule 2(1)(b); costs
Practice Areas
This judgment dismisses a tort action by 810 plaintiffs against 18 defendants arising from a September 2020 water disruption in Wangsa Maju, Kuala Lumpur. The High Court determined the threshold issue of locus standi after the first plaintiff (PW-1), a former Member of Parliament, testified as sole witness. The Court held this was a private law tort action requiring strict standing requirements, not public interest litigation. PW-1 lacked personal standing, having resided outside the affected area with no personal water disruption. The action failed as a representative proceeding under Order 15 Rule 12 ROC 2012, lacked endorsement under Order 6 Rule 2(1)(b) and proper authorization. The remaining 809 plaintiffs adduced no evidence and defects emerged where 103 plaintiffs with non-existent identity card numbers, 8 deceased plaintiffs, 3 undischarged bankrupts without DGI sanction, and 8 residing outside the affected area. PW-1 admitted inability to prove any claim and lacked written authorisation from the plaintiffs. Locus standi; representative action; tort; private law standing; Order 15 Rule 12; Order 6 Rule 2(1)(b); costs
Judges (1)
Parties (815)
Jabatan Alam Sekitar Defendant Jabatan Pengairan & Saliran Defendant Kerajaan Malaysia Defendant Kerajaan Negeri Selangor Defendant MENTERI BESAR SELANGOR (PEMERBADANAN) Defendant MENTERI SUMBER ASLI DAN ALAM SEKITAR Defendant Majlis Perbandaran Selayang Defendant PAKAR SCIENO TW Sdn Bhd Defendant PENGURUSAN AIR SELANGOR Sdn Bhd Defendant Pendakwa Raya Defendant SURUHANJAYA PERKHIDMATAN AIR NEGARA Defendant YIP CHEE SENG & SONS Sdn Bhd Defendant Aananthy a/p Ramanathan Plaintiff Ab Hamid bin Muhammad Plaintiff Ab Kadir Ahmad Plaintiff Abd Azis bin Selamat Plaintiff Abd Mutalib bin Ahmad Plaintiff Abd Rais bin Abdul Rahman Plaintiff Abdul Aziz bin Murad Plaintiff Abdul Halim bin Abdullah Plaintiff Abdul Latif bin Mohammed Plaintiff Abdul Rashid bin Hassan Plaintiff Abdullah Ab. Hamid Plaintiff Abu Bakar bin Abdul Ghani Plaintiff Ahmad Zaki b. Kamaruddin Plaintiff Ahmad bin Embong Plaintiff Aidil Adha bin Rahimin Plaintiff Aiswariah a/p Sivalingam Plaintiff Alice Siew Onn Tze Plaintiff Amiruddin bin Abbas Plaintiff Andan Hanim binti Othman Plaintiff Anetha a/p Vallaitham Pillai Plaintiff Ang Bee Kee Plaintiff Ang Hua Sang Plaintiff Ang Pei Lin Plaintiff Ang Suet Mooi Plaintiff Ang Thean Seng Plaintiff Angel Chan Ann Qi Plaintiff Anne Floryena a/p Anarchi Muthu Plaintiff Arasan a/l Ponnusamy Plaintiff Ardik Elieskusmiran Amirudin Plaintiff Arief Izuadin bin Ahmad Jefferi Plaintiff Ariff Muqri Aqil bin Ariffin Plaintiff Aruf bin Abd Hamid Plaintiff Arumugam a/l Kuppan Plaintiff Asmuni bin Nafiah Plaintiff Asrizal bin Nurajin Plaintiff Atan bin Mahat Plaintiff Au-yong Peng Kwan Plaintiff Authoriti Pengurusan Air Selangor Defendant Aw Wai Yen Plaintiff Ayammah a/p Govindasamy Plaintiff Azhar bin Mohd Taib Plaintiff Azizah binti Ali Plaintiff Azlan A. Aziz Plaintiff Azman Mohd Kasim Plaintiff Azman bin Yusof Plaintiff Babul Abbas bin Abd Aziz Plaintiff Badariah binti Abdul Rahman Plaintiff Balakrishnan M. Vellasamy Plaintiff Bongsu bin Dahlan Plaintiff Brian Ling Yew Shen Plaintiff C. Nagesvari a/p S. Cholechamy Plaintiff Carol Shanti a/p John Raman Plaintiff Chai Chon Hok Plaintiff Chai Kim Son Plaintiff Chak Choon Bok Plaintiff Champa Kavelly a/p Krisnan Plaintiff Chan Hoi Kuin Plaintiff Chan Joon Tuck Plaintiff Chan Kah Choon Plaintiff Chan Keong Plaintiff Chan Men Chu Plaintiff Chan Soy Lan @ Chan Koon Thye Plaintiff Chan Tak Lee Plaintiff Chan Tak Oon Plaintiff Chandra Kumar a/l Govindasamy Plaintiff Chandra Mohan a/l Krishnan Plaintiff Chandra a/p Rajoo Plaintiff Chang Yoke Lian Plaintiff Charan Raj a/l Chandra Kumar Plaintiff Chau Wai Meng Plaintiff Che Nor Azila binti Cae Yusoff Plaintiff Cheah Ching Mooi Plaintiff Cheah Poh Mooi Plaintiff Chen Oi Keng Plaintiff Cheong Tuck Sang Plaintiff Cheong Yoke Sum Plaintiff Chew Ken Meng Plaintiff Chin Chui Thai @chan Choi Thai Plaintiff Chin Kam Lam Plaintiff Chin Ng Mooi Plaintiff Ching Hong Bing Plaintiff Chocolate Turbo Trading Plaintiff Choi Meng Yet Plaintiff Chong Chow Ming Plaintiff Chong Kui Ling Plaintiff Chong Lai Ping Plaintiff Chong Li Ling Plaintiff Chong Nyim Choy Plaintiff Chong Suh Ngoh Plaintiff Chong Wah Yin Plaintiff Chong Yock Ling Plaintiff Chong Yoke Thoh Plaintiff Chong Yuet Kuan Plaintiff Choo Sin Choy Plaintiff Choo Soong Mooi Plaintiff Chooi Moy Plaintiff Chook Kin Heng Plaintiff Choong Chee Leong @ Chang Chee Leong Plaintiff Chu Chooi Ling Plaintiff Chu Hoon Ping Plaintiff Chua Kim Plaintiff Chua Pem Leong Plaintiff Chua Poh Choo Plaintiff Daniel Rajendran a/l Thangvello Plaintiff Datin Paduka Dr. Tan Yee Kew Plaintiff Davidson a/l Maruthamuthu Plaintiff Devi Bavani a/p Subramaniam Plaintiff Dewi Murni Harun Plaintiff Diong Kee Ling Plaintiff Ee Egin @ Eeh Cheng Jin Plaintiff Ee Wai Leong Plaintiff Elanjeran a/l Sadasivam Plaintiff Elanselvam a/l Sivam Plaintiff Endut binti Awang Plaintiff Eng Kok Fei Plaintiff Faizah binti Jusoh Plaintiff Farah Wahidah binti Mohd Suliman Plaintiff Farrah Ermilda binti Aminuddin Plaintiff Fatimah binti Ahmad Plaintiff Fatimah binti Idris Plaintiff Fauziah binti Embong Plaintiff Fong Ah Lian Plaintiff Fong Yim Fun Plaintiff Foo Ah Ang Plaintiff Foo Chee Foon Plaintiff Foo May Fong Plaintiff Foo Shin Ling Plaintiff Foo Yoke Wha Plaintiff Foon Soy Sang Plaintiff Foong Mun Ho Plaintiff Gan Ah Luan Plaintiff Gan Ah Yew Plaintiff Gan Bee Choo Plaintiff Gan Jiat Huei Plaintiff Gan Leong Chai Plaintiff Gan Lip Hong Plaintiff Gan Siw Mooi Plaintiff Ganison a/l Muniandy Plaintiff Geetha a/p R. Krishnamoorthy Plaintiff Goh Heng Keong Plaintiff Goh Kim Lim Plaintiff Goh Lai Chee Plaintiff Goh Ming Moi Plaintiff Goh Sui Kuan Plaintiff Gow Chong Liang Plaintiff Guan Saw Kuan Plaintiff Gwendolyn Lai Wei Lin Plaintiff H. Grace Piyaseelee Perera Plaintiff Habsah Md Nordin Plaintiff Hamdan bin Abd Motalib Plaintiff Hasan Basri b. Samion Plaintiff Hasan bin Yaacub Plaintiff Hashim b. Jaafar Plaintiff Hasmidariza binti Mat Hussin Plaintiff Hassan bin Haroon Plaintiff Hawa Natasya binti Abdullah Plaintiff Hayati Samsudin Plaintiff Hazizi bin Hashim Plaintiff Hee Chee Choong Plaintiff Hema Durga a/p S.gunasagaran Plaintiff Hilmeriza bin Yaacob Plaintiff Ho Hoong Fatt Plaintiff Ho Kien Kai Plaintiff Ho Koon Guan Plaintiff Ho Peng @ Ho Yoke Leng Plaintiff Ho Soon Huan Plaintiff Ho Tat Ying Plaintiff Hon Foong Yee Plaintiff Hong Geok Ean Plaintiff Hoo Foo Sin Plaintiff Hoon Kam Fook Plaintiff Hoong Loe Hing Plaintiff Hotimah binti Dasir Plaintiff How Cheng Peng @ Low Cheng Peng Plaintiff How Chin Ang Plaintiff How Pek Hap Plaintiff How Sook Ying Plaintiff Hue Alan Plaintiff Indra a/p Rengasamy Plaintiff Indrani @ Suranam a/p Mahadevan Plaintiff Indrani a/p Kanasegran Plaintiff Indrani a/p Vadivelu Plaintiff Intan binti Mustafa Plaintiff Irfan bin Roslan Plaintiff Irwan Syah B Acisman Plaintiff Isahbee binti Sini Mohamed Plaintiff Islahuddin bin Idha Nawawi Plaintiff Ismail bin Kadar Plaintiff Ismail bin Md. Yan Plaintiff Ismiriyah binti Muhammed Plaintiff Ja'afar bin Haron Plaintiff Jaidin bin Ali @ Login Plaintiff Jamaliah binti Ramli Plaintiff Jamaluddin bin Md Mansor Plaintiff Jamilah binti Lyazid Plaintiff Jang Poh Hong Plaintiff Jasmani bin Osman Plaintiff Jasphar Tommy Millicent Plaintiff Jay Boon Kiat Plaintiff Jaya a/p Marimuthu Plaintiff Jayabalan a/l Cholechamy Plaintiff Jeyamiah a/p Suppiah Plaintiff Johnny Nguoi Yew Ming Plaintiff Joseph Kumar a/l Vincent Plaintiff Josephin Tan Kim Lean Plaintiff Josephine a/p V. Kuthar Plaintiff Jothee a/l Karupayah Plaintiff Juliana binti Buyong Plaintiff Junaidah binti Ahmad Razali Plaintiff K. Ponnamah a/p R. Krishnan Plaintiff K. Thalagauathy a/p Krishan Plaintiff Kala Devi a/p Maniam Plaintiff Kaladevi a/p Balakrishnan Plaintiff Kaladevi a/p Ramachanthiran Plaintiff Kalai Selvi Avvai Plaintiff Kalaivanai a/p Karuppiah Plaintiff Kaliamah a/p Munniandy Plaintiff Kamala a/p Cheria Kannan Plaintiff Kamaruddin bin Selamat Plaintiff Kamarudin bin Saji Plaintiff Kamarul Shazli bin Ali Plaintiff Kamsiah binti Mohamed Hanifah Plaintiff Kamsol bin Mohd Yahya Plaintiff Kanagavendan a/l Dolah Plaintiff Kang Loo See Plaintiff Kanniamah a/p Munusamy Plaintiff Kasturi a/p Ramanathian Plaintiff Kavita a/p Periasamy Plaintiff Kerisnan @ Krishnan a/l Maniam Plaintiff Keythesri a/p M. Manickam Plaintiff Khairul Salleh bin Ishak Plaintiff Khalid bin Mohamad Plaintiff Khaw Khai Kim Plaintiff Khoo Ah Ba Plaintiff Khoo Way Shing Plaintiff Khor Yew Poon Plaintiff Koh Jid Ken Plaintiff Kokila Wani a/p Munusamy Plaintiff Kong Aying Plaintiff Kong Ngan Hooi Plaintiff Kong Wai Keat Plaintiff Krishnakumari a/p Ramanaidu Plaintiff Krishnaveni a/p Palani Plaintiff Ku Chau Fah Plaintiff Ku Song Heng Plaintiff Kuan Mei Lan Plaintiff Kuar Thiam Tiew @ Ah Beng Plaintiff Kugeelam a/p Subramaniam Plaintiff Kuk Suh Tong Plaintiff Kulanthavelu a/l K. Vellu Plaintiff Kumar a/l Arjunan Plaintiff Kumar a/l Ganison Plaintiff Kunthy a/p C. V. Samuel Plaintiff Lai Chee Leng Plaintiff Lai Chee Siong Plaintiff Lai Chow Meng Plaintiff Lai Mook Thai Plaintiff Lai Siew Leong Plaintiff Lan Chat Man Plaintiff Lan Jie Fei Plaintiff Lau Ah Kim Plaintiff Lau Ah Qua Plaintiff Lau Ee Teong Plaintiff Law Kon Shiam @ Low Kon Song Plaintiff Law Ngan Looi Plaintiff Law Seng Kong Plaintiff Lawrence a/l Munusamy Plaintiff Ledy Plaintiff Lee Ah Thye Plaintiff Lee Bee Ling Plaintiff Lee Chai Hoong Plaintiff Lee Chee Choong Plaintiff Lee Chee Keong Plaintiff Lee Cheng How Plaintiff Lee Chew Lin Plaintiff Lee Chin Hong Plaintiff Lee Chow Kong Plaintiff Lee Chuan Heng Plaintiff Lee Chun Tack Plaintiff Lee Foong Pin Plaintiff Lee Guat Khim Plaintiff Lee Hae Kin Plaintiff Lee Keim Hok @ Lee Sak Siang Plaintiff Lee Kim Choo Plaintiff Lee Lay Choon Plaintiff Lee Li Hwa Plaintiff Lee Mooi Plaintiff Lee Ping Sim Plaintiff Lee Sai Yah Plaintiff Lee Seng Chong Plaintiff Lee Seng Wei Plaintiff Lee Shii Ler Plaintiff Lee Siew Keong Plaintiff Lee Siow Wah Plaintiff Lee Swee Kim Plaintiff Lee Wah Kee Plaintiff Lee Wei Na Plaintiff Lee Woon Har Plaintiff Lee Yew Mooi Plaintiff Lee Yin Kiew Plaintiff Lee Ying Plaintiff Lee Yok Lan Plaintiff Lee Yoke Chow Plaintiff Lem Sing Plaintiff Leong Choe Lan Plaintiff Leong Kong Woh Plaintiff Leong Kum Chin @ Leong Kim Foon Plaintiff Leong May Lee Plaintiff Leong Sang Plaintiff Leong Tien Loong Plaintiff Leong Weng Onn Plaintiff Leow Sew Choon Plaintiff Letchimy a/p Mayavan Plaintiff Letchumi a/p Subramaniam Plaintiff Lew Yen Mooi Plaintiff Ley Teng Plaintiff Liew Kon Seng Plaintiff Liew Lai King Plaintiff Liew San Thin Plaintiff Liew Tong Kan Plaintiff Lim Ah Chai @ Lim Chwee Loh Plaintiff Lim Chee Keong Plaintiff Lim Cheng Sang Plaintiff Lim Chok Weai Plaintiff Lim Chook Yin Plaintiff Lim Fong Yoke Plaintiff Lim Geok Hwa Plaintiff Lim Hue Hun Plaintiff Lim Kim Moi Plaintiff Lim Koom Kee Plaintiff Lim Kwee Yan Plaintiff Lim Lay Chui @ Lim Chooi Pheow Plaintiff Lim Leong Boo Plaintiff Lim Long Hock Plaintiff Lim Man Leong Plaintiff Lim Poh Swan Plaintiff Lim Sear Tee Plaintiff Lim Seng Eng Plaintiff Lim Seok Foong Plaintiff Lim Siew Koon Plaintiff Lim Siew Lai Plaintiff Lim Siong Seng Plaintiff Lim Soo Ling Plaintiff Lim Suan Mai Plaintiff Lim Swee Ngoh Plaintiff Lim Yan Hoi Plaintiff Lim Yaw Fong Plaintiff Lim Yok Kee Plaintiff Lim Yoke Yee Plaintiff Lim Yuen Chin Plaintiff Lin Lee Kian Plaintiff Lin Wei Ching Plaintiff Ling Ke Kiong Plaintiff Lock Chee Hoong Plaintiff Loh Foh Long Plaintiff Loh Swee Sin Plaintiff Loh Yu Lan Plaintiff Loke Hong Chai Plaintiff Long Mei Lin Plaintiff Loong Keng Hwa Plaintiff Lou Chee Weng Plaintiff Low Ek Mooi Plaintiff Low Guan Hong Plaintiff Low Guat Yan Plaintiff Low Hai Chuang Plaintiff Low Lee Choo Plaintiff Low Lee Fong Plaintiff Low Lee Sen Plaintiff Low Peng Shong Plaintiff Low Soo Leng Plaintiff Low Sook Weah Plaintiff Low Yee Shy Plaintiff Lu Ah Kam Plaintiff M.s. Selvakumaran a/l Suppiah Plaintiff Maalini a/p Naraianasamy Plaintiff Madiah binti Sahak Plaintiff Mages a/p Tangarajah Plaintiff Mageswari a/p Samikanoo Plaintiff Mahaletchimy a/p Poongan Plaintiff Mahalingam a/l Supiah Plaintiff Malar a/p Gopal Plaintiff Maliha a/p Jayakodi Plaintiff Malisa binti Mohd Fauzi Plaintiff Mangatkarasi a/p Tharumalingam Plaintiff Mansor bin Mohd Amin Plaintiff Margaret Rudd a/p Thomas Rudd Plaintiff Mariappan a/l Velayutham Plaintiff Marni binti Musa Plaintiff Mary a/p Rayappan Plaintiff Marziah bt Md Yusof Plaintiff Masimalei a/l Marudamuthu Plaintiff Md Akhir bin Piee Plaintiff Md Ibrahim Marican bin Md David Marican Plaintiff Md Sahadan bin Noor Plaintiff Meenachi a/p Supramaniam Plaintiff Megawati binti Rasli Plaintiff Mersiah binti Ismail Plaintiff Moghan a/l Poorasamy Plaintiff Mohamad Akhir bin Abdul Hamid Plaintiff Mohamad Man Plaintiff Mohamad Nazir bin Nasar Plaintiff Mohamad Nor bin Rahmat Plaintiff Mohamed Noorsyafiq bin Shamsudin Plaintiff Mohammad Sayoti bin Ismail Plaintiff Mohammad Zahir bin Mat Noh Plaintiff Mohana Sundaram a/l Sivasamy Plaintiff Mohanadas a/l C Arumugham Plaintiff Mohd Al-hafiz bin Mohd Zin Plaintiff Mohd Azmi bin Bahari Plaintiff Mohd Azrilhisyam bin Rosden Plaintiff Mohd Dewa bin Abd Rasip Plaintiff Mohd Edee bin Rahim Plaintiff Mohd Fadzlan bin Abdullah Plaintiff Mohd Fairouz bin Mohd Yaakop Plaintiff Mohd Faizol bin Muhd Bahor Plaintiff Mohd Izham bin Shafie Plaintiff Mohd Kamil bin Mohd Kassim Plaintiff Mohd Noh bin Mokhtar Plaintiff Mohd Nor @ Manoharan bin Abdullah Plaintiff Mohd Sabri bin Murat Plaintiff Mohd Said bin Hj Shari Plaintiff Mohd Saifudin b. Abd Rahman Plaintiff Mohd Shafiee @ Johari bin Shamsuddin Plaintiff Mohd Supian bin Din Plaintiff Mohonraj a/l Vijakumar Plaintiff Mok Choy Peng Plaintiff Moo Yok Cheng Plaintiff Muhamad Lambau Plaintiff Muhamad Mahir B Othman Plaintiff Muhammad Abdul Kadir bin Salleh Plaintiff Muhammad Farhan bin Idzwan Shahredza Plaintiff Muhammad Farid bin Abdul Latif Plaintiff Muhammad Firdaus bin Adi Plaintiff Muhammad Luqman Hakim bin Mohamad Yasri Plaintiff Muhammad Naqi bin Badi'ual Azmi Plaintiff Muhammad Nasiruddin bin Mohd Hanafiah Plaintiff Muhammad Shafie bin Johari Plaintiff Muhammad Yusuff bin Harun Plaintiff Muhammed Rydzal bin Ab Rahim Plaintiff Muhilan a/l Perumal Plaintiff Mulyasih bt Bunari Plaintiff Muniamah a/p Thillamuthu Plaintiff Murni binti Che Kob Plaintiff Murthy a/l Raju Plaintiff Musa Man Plaintiff Muthoo a/l Ayavoo Plaintiff Na Bee Eng Plaintiff Nadiawati binti Muslim Plaintiff Nagaiyah a/l Munian Plaintiff Nageswary a/p V. Ramasamy Plaintiff Nagisveri a/p Sinnandy Plaintiff Nalini a/p A Munusamy Plaintiff Navammal a/p Subramaniam Plaintiff Navammal a/p Subramaniam (navas Corner) Plaintiff Navvarrina Kaur Bajwa a/p Daljit S Plaintiff Ng Ah Hwa Plaintiff Ng Ah Lin Plaintiff Ng Ai Lian Plaintiff Ng Boon Hock Plaintiff Ng Chong @ Ng Chui Chong Plaintiff Ng Eang Choo Plaintiff Ng Futt Yew Plaintiff Ng Gan Leng Plaintiff Ng Guan Bee Plaintiff Ng Kok Chin Plaintiff Ng Lay Khim Plaintiff Ng Lee Ping Plaintiff Ng Liong Sie Plaintiff Ng Oineng Plaintiff Ng Sau Kam Plaintiff Ng Siew Lian Plaintiff Ng Wee Soy Plaintiff Ng Yoke Kiew Plaintiff Ngoh Yew Kong Plaintiff Ngooi Kim Kee Plaintiff Ngooi Yuet Ming Plaintiff Nik Muhamad Arash bin Mohd Naim Plaintiff Nizam binti Mohammad Yusoff Plaintiff Nokalama a/p Rameloo Plaintiff Nookku Raju Plaintiff Noor Afis bin Khoary Plaintiff Noor Azli bin Abas Plaintiff Noor'azrien binti Lokman Plaintiff Noorhisam bin Roos Affandey Plaintiff Noorlia binti Mohd Noorddin Plaintiff Nor Azura binti Ariffin Plaintiff Nor Emawahioa binti Maruddin Plaintiff Nor Fariza binti Yusop Plaintiff Nor Izzati binti Mhd Tarmizi Plaintiff Norbaini Bte Abd Latiff Plaintiff Nordin b. Hasan Plaintiff Norfhadilah Ilani bt Rusli Plaintiff Norhan bin Haji Mohd Nor Plaintiff Norhasnidar Akmal binti Khairul Amri Plaintiff Norhayati bt. Abd Majid Plaintiff Norisha Afiza bt Yahaya Plaintiff Norita bt Nordin Plaintiff Norizal bin Harun Plaintiff Norizan binti Abdullah Plaintiff Norlida binti Abas Plaintiff Normawati binti A. Hariri Plaintiff Norsyahila binti Mohd Yunus Plaintiff Norull Man bin Shafie Plaintiff Norzamri bin Muhamad Plaintiff Nur Afina binti Muhammad Lambau Plaintiff Nur Afiqah Binil Mohtar Apandi Plaintiff Nur Azlina binti Muhamad Lambau Plaintiff Nur Farhana binti Abdullah Plaintiff Nur Shida Chau binti Abdullah Plaintiff Nur Syuhada binti Roslan Plaintiff Nurbaizura bt Azizul Hassan Plaintiff Nurul Farhah Mohd Asnadi Plaintiff Nurulain binti Matlob Plaintiff Oh Boon Huat Plaintiff Oh Chee Peng Plaintiff Oh Kem Ten Plaintiff Oii Chin Hock Plaintiff Omar bin Bahron Plaintiff Ong Lewi Plaintiff Ong Sing Chuai Plaintiff Ong Teck Chuan Plaintiff Ooi Kim Geok Plaintiff P. Thilaga a/p R. Palaniandy Plaintiff Padmini a/p Manikam Plaintiff Pan Yong Po Plaintiff Pang Seng Chong Plaintiff Parathi a/l Kesavan Plaintiff Parathy a/p Govidarajoo Plaintiff Pee Ching Hing Plaintiff Pee Sew Chin Plaintiff Peh Lay Chin Plaintiff Pek Kien Heng Plaintiff Perumal a/l Chinaya Plaintiff Peter a/l Anthony Plaintiff Prema a/p Arumugam Plaintiff Priyanka a/p Selvam Plaintiff Pushpa a/p Somalu Plaintiff Puspa a/p Kuppan Plaintiff Puteri Sharmeen bt Al Azad Anor George Plaintiff Puvaneswary a/p Ramasamy Plaintiff R. Letchimy a/p S. Raju Plaintiff Rafizah bt Bakar Plaintiff Raja Manikam a/l Munisamy Plaintiff Raja Norsidah bt Raja Abdul Jalil Plaintiff Rajinderan a/l Suppiah Plaintiff Raman a/l R.suppian Plaintiff Ramlah bt Habib Plaintiff Ramlee bin Md Nor Plaintiff Ramlee bin Mohd Ghani Plaintiff Randhy Afandhy b. Ruslan Plaintiff Rasyidi bin Sulaiman Plaintiff Razali bin Abu Bakar Plaintiff Rehdy Khairil bin Mohd Kamil Plaintiff Rehmy Khairil bin Mohd Kamil Plaintiff Rewathy a/p Ganesan Plaintiff Robert William Wilfred Plaintiff Robert a/l Subramaniam Plaintiff Rohaini binti Senik Plaintiff Roslan bin Abd Kadir Plaintiff Roslani binti Yasin Plaintiff Rosli bin Din Plaintiff Rosli bin Hassan Plaintiff Roslin bin Baser Plaintiff Roslina bt. Sharudin Plaintiff Rosmi bin Kerya Plaintiff Ruban Raj a/l Kunasiagran Plaintiff Rubiah binti Ahmad Salleh Plaintiff Rusli bin Mat Ajid Plaintiff Rusnani binti Yamat Plaintiff S. Chandran a/l Subramaniam Plaintiff S. Puspalatha a/p Sundramoorthy Plaintiff S. Thalakham a/p Sinnasamy Plaintiff Sabapathy a/l Muthoo Plaintiff Sabariah binti Nalim Plaintiff Sabarudin bin Hamzah Plaintiff Sabriah binti Mohammad Plaintiff Sabrina binti Sahul Hamid Plaintiff Saemah bt Ithnin Plaintiff Sah Kum Tai Plaintiff Sah Thye Plaintiff Saimah binti Muhammad Plaintiff Salehudin bin Sharif Plaintiff Salina bt Abdullah Plaintiff Sallowi Ngah Plaintiff Sam Hoo Wai Plaintiff Sapuan bin Milun Plaintiff Saraswathi Devi a/p Ramalingam Plaintiff Saraswathi a/p Kuppusamy Plaintiff Sathia Rooban a/l Seenavasnam Plaintiff Seah Huat Chai Plaintiff See Ai Suat Plaintiff See Ai Teng Plaintiff See Lay Hoon Plaintiff See Quai Sen Plaintiff Selvarani Nadesan Plaintiff Selvarani a/p M Vadamalay Plaintiff Senin bin Sarif Plaintiff Shaharudin b. Mahmud Plaintiff Shahran bin Yusup Plaintiff Shak Li Li Plaintiff Shamsuddin bin Ali Plaintiff Shariffah binti Ibrahim Plaintiff Sharudin bin Abd Rashid Plaintiff Sheela Devi a/p Paniaselvam Plaintiff Shein Kim Chu Plaintiff Sia Yook Lean Plaintiff Siew May Kuan Plaintiff Sim Siew Yin Plaintiff Sim You Ang Plaintiff Sing Kwee Wan Plaintiff Sinniah a/l S.raju Plaintiff Sirajudin bin Abdul Jabbar Plaintiff Siti Aishah binti Zulkifly Plaintiff Siti Norwana binti Zakaria Plaintiff Siti Zaitun binti Shamsury Plaintiff Siti Zauwiah bt Yahaya Plaintiff Siva Devi a/p Subramaniam Plaintiff Sivalingam a/l A. S Balachandra Plaintiff Sivam a/l Sankran Plaintiff Sivananthini a/p Velaizam Plaintiff Sofia binti Tarmizi Plaintiff Soh Ah Ngan Plaintiff Soh Qui Yong Plaintiff Soo Chee Toong Plaintiff Soo Fook Sam Plaintiff Soon Yoon Wah Plaintiff Soong Sum Mun Plaintiff Sow Chee Sioy Plaintiff Sri Tuti binti Syarifudin Plaintiff Su Wei Siong Plaintiff Subbhash a/l Puvaneswaran Plaintiff Subramaniam a/l Ramalingam Plaintiff Sujindran a/l Baloo Plaintiff Sumathy a/p Dheven Tharan Plaintiff Sumayama a/p Sumid Kumar Plaintiff Sunayana a/p Sunil Kumar Plaintiff Suppama a/p Muniandy Plaintiff Suseela a/p Rengasamy Plaintiff Susila a/p Ramasamy Plaintiff Suzannah binti Mokhtar Plaintiff Swee Chong Meng Plaintiff Syahirah binti Hermadi Plaintiff Taig Thain Ching Plaintiff Tajul Ahmad Amin bin Tajudin Plaintiff Tamil Chilwi a/p Satkunam Plaintiff Tamil Selvi a/p Subramaniam Plaintiff Tamilchelvi a/p Kasinathan Plaintiff Tamilselvi a/p Ponnusamy Plaintiff Tan Chee Siong Plaintiff Tan Chin Kok Plaintiff Tan Fong Chai Plaintiff Tan Foong Chee Plaintiff Tan Kam Wah Plaintiff Tan Kean Teck Plaintiff Tan Kian Loong Plaintiff Tan Kim Moi Plaintiff Tan Kok Long Plaintiff Tan Lai Kee Plaintiff Tan Lay Ching Plaintiff Tan Lay Hoon Plaintiff Tan Lay Mei Plaintiff Tan Mui Hwa Plaintiff Tan Peck Yong Plaintiff Tan Poh Gek Plaintiff Tan Poh Hong Plaintiff Tan Poh Yin Plaintiff Tan Siew Leng Plaintiff Tan Suek Kay Plaintiff Tan Thean Leng Plaintiff Tan Wee Hong Plaintiff Tan Wooi Kiam Plaintiff Tan Yen Ten Plaintiff Tan Zhen Yi Plaintiff Tang Ming Hong Plaintiff Tang Peck Heong Plaintiff Tang Wai San Plaintiff Tay Chong Jueh Plaintiff Tee Phuay Bee Plaintiff Teh Ah Hoe @ Hong Yap Lan Plaintiff Teh Ah Nee Plaintiff Teh Keat Eong Plaintiff Teng Pang Wu Plaintiff Teo Bee Thai Plaintiff Teo Moon bin @ Hew Moon bin Plaintiff Teoh Poh Heok Plaintiff Teoh Siok Cheng Plaintiff Teong Tee Hong @ Chang Yong Wah Plaintiff Tet Tuan Plaintiff Tey Wee Ling Plaintiff Tg. Zakir bin Tg. Zahid Plaintiff Tham Kam Fong Plaintiff Thamotharan a/l Sinnan Plaintiff Thanaletchumy a/p Poongan Plaintiff Thang Eng Tai Plaintiff Thanushia a/p Rajandran Plaintiff Theresa a/p Alburnus Plaintiff Thilagavathi a/p A. Kuppusamy Plaintiff Thin Siew Lay Plaintiff Thin Swee Hong Plaintiff Thin Swee Huat Plaintiff Thinakaram a/l Varathen Plaintiff Thiviya Sree a/p Thiagu Plaintiff Thulosimany Plaintiff Tiang Pei Sim Plaintiff Tiang Pei Sin Plaintiff Ting Go Hwee @ Tee Go Hwee Plaintiff Ting Tam Hok @ Tan Tam Hok Plaintiff Toh Ah Haee Plaintiff Too Siong Fat Plaintiff Tsen Kim Tai Plaintiff Tung Moi Plaintiff Umathevan a/l Vellu Plaintiff Umikalsom binti Hamid Plaintiff Ung Han Wei Plaintiff V. Anjalai Davi a/p Veerasamy Plaintiff V. Poongavanam a/p V. Veerasamy Plaintiff Valliamah a/p K.vellu Plaintiff Varoothama a/p Subramaniam Plaintiff Vasanda a/p Vythiligam Plaintiff Vasenthi a/p Perumal Plaintiff Vejayan a/l Cheria Kannan Plaintiff Velautham a/l Kaniapen Plaintiff Vellammal a/p Vadamalay Plaintiff Vellayammal a/p Karuppaman Plaintiff Velliammah a/p Karuppiah Plaintiff Venkadeswari a/p R Letchimanan Plaintiff Vijakumar a/l Mariappan Plaintiff Vijaya Kumari a/p Kannipan Plaintiff Vijayaletchumi a/p Muniandy Plaintiff Vijeyalechumy a/p Muthu Plaintiff Vineswary a/p Rajoo Plaintiff Vinodkumar a/l Ganesan Plaintiff Wai Ying Keong Plaintiff Wajdi bin Mohamad Plaintiff Wan Zainab binti Wan Yahya Plaintiff Wang Tung Sheng Plaintiff Wha Chong Foong Plaintiff Wong Chee @ Wong Yoke Soo Plaintiff Wong Chin Chin Plaintiff Wong Choon Loy Plaintiff Wong Kum Hoong Plaintiff Wong Lye Hoong Plaintiff Wong Moon Chai Plaintiff Wong Seon Keng Plaintiff Wong Sheau Wah Plaintiff Wong Sock Ling Plaintiff Wong Soo Foong Plaintiff Wong Suit Ngor Plaintiff Wong Yoke Mit Plaintiff Wong Yoke Yen Plaintiff Woo Leong Plaintiff Yaakob bin Basir Plaintiff Yahya binti Budin Plaintiff Yap Ay Kim Plaintiff Yap Chee Yin Plaintiff Yap Eng Plaintiff Yap Kew Hiong Plaintiff Yap Kim Choi @ Yap Kim Choy Plaintiff Yap Kim Fook @ Yap Fook Plaintiff Yap Koon Seng Plaintiff Yap Lai Ngor Plaintiff Yap Say Moy Plaintiff Yap Siew Hwa Plaintiff Yap Swee Foong Plaintiff Yap Wei Ling Plaintiff Yap Yoke Keong Plaintiff Yeap Mei Har Plaintiff Yee Choon Wai Plaintiff Yee Yaun Plaintiff Yeow Chow Cheong Plaintiff Yin Vui Kiong Plaintiff Yip Choi Wah Plaintiff Yogesvary a/p Muniyandi Plaintiff Yong Kim Chan Plaintiff Yong Kong Hong Plaintiff Yong Moy Plaintiff Yong Onn Tai Plaintiff Yong Siew Hee Plaintiff Yong Woon Hin Plaintiff Yoong Khai Hau Plaintiff Yoong Sau Lon Plaintiff Yue Loi Thoi Plaintiff Yuen Kwai Chun Plaintiff Yuen Kwai Mu Plaintiff Yuen Kwai Tui Plaintiff Yuvarani a/p Nadarajah Plaintiff Zahairulazhar bin Zakaria Plaintiff Zaharah Ton binti Ahmad Hejas Plaintiff Zaharah bt Awang Kechik Plaintiff Zainab binti Yusof Plaintiff Zainab binti Zainal Plaintiff Zainal Abidin bin Idirs Plaintiff Zaiton binti Baharom Plaintiff Zakaria bin Atan Plaintiff Zaleha binti Daud Plaintiff Zalina bt Yaccob Plaintiff Zarina binti Abdul Halim Plaintiff Zarinah binti Mohd Kassim Plaintiff Zuhaimy Zahari Plaintiff Zul Amin Nordin Plaintiff Zulrahim Ismail Plaintiff Zuraini Alias Plaintiff Zuriana binti Ashaari Plaintiff
Case Significance
1. ) DATIN PADUKA DR. TAN YEE KEW 2. ) VIJAYA KUMARI A/P KANNIPAN 3. ) LEE CH... is a High Court (Mahkamah Tinggi) decision dated November 3, 2025 (citation: wa-21ncvc-80-04-2021). The case was decided by Arziah binti Mohamed Apandi.
Key issues: Locus standi; representative action; tort; private law standing; Order 15 Rule 12; Order 6 Rule 2(1)(b); costs.
What was the outcome of 1. ) DATIN PADUKA DR. TAN YEE KEW 2. ) VIJAYA KUMARI A/P KANNIPAN 3. ) LEE CH...?
1. ) DATIN PADUKA DR. TAN YEE KEW 2. ) VIJAYA KUMARI A/P KANNIPAN 3. ) LEE CH... is a High Court decision dated November 3, 2025. The case was heard by Arziah binti Mohamed Apandi. See the full judgment for details.