MENTERI SUMBER ASLI DAN ALAM SEKITAR

Organisation 3 cases

About MENTERI SUMBER ASLI DAN ALAM SEKITAR

MENTERI SUMBER ASLI DAN ALAM SEKITAR appears as a party in 3 judgments in the MY Case Law database, spanning June 2025 to November 2025. MENTERI SUMBER ASLI DAN ALAM SEKITAR appeared as respondent in 2 cases, defendant in 1 case. Cases span the Court of Appeal (1), Federal Court (1), High Court (1).

How many court cases involve MENTERI SUMBER ASLI DAN ALAM SEKITAR?

MENTERI SUMBER ASLI DAN ALAM SEKITAR appears in 3 published judgments from June 2025 to November 2025. Most commonly as respondent (2 cases).

Practice Areas

- leave to appeal against the decision of the Court of Appeal dated 24.6.2025, which dismissed the Applicant’s appeal against the decision of the High Court dated 27.10.2021, which dismissed the application for judicial review for order of Mandamus; 1 Mandamus 1 This judgment dismisses a tort action by 810 plaintiffs against 18 defendants arising from a September 2020 water disruption in Wangsa Maju, Kuala Lumpur. The High Court determined the threshold issue of locus standi after the first plaintiff (PW-1), a former Member of Parliament, testified as sole witness. The Court held this was a private law tort action requiring strict standing requirements, not public interest litigation. PW-1 lacked personal standing, having resided outside the affected area with no personal water disruption. The action failed as a representative proceeding under Order 15 Rule 12 ROC 2012, lacked endorsement under Order 6 Rule 2(1)(b) and proper authorization. The remaining 809 plaintiffs adduced no evidence and defects emerged where 103 plaintiffs with non-existent identity card numbers, 8 deceased plaintiffs, 3 undischarged bankrupts without DGI sanction, and 8 residing outside the affected area. PW-1 admitted inability to prove any claim and lacked written authorisation from the plaintiffs. 1 Locus standi; representative action; tort; private law standing; Order 15 Rule 12; Order 6 Rule 2(1)(b); costs 1

Respondent (2)

08f-250-07-2025w MYFC

Semantan Estate (1952) Sdn Bhd v 1. ) Kerajaan Malaysia 2. ) PERSURUHJAYA TANAH PERSEKUTUAN 3. ) MENTERI YANG BERTANGGUNGJAWAB BAGI TANAH DI WILAYAH PERSEKUTUAN 4. ) MENTERI SUMBER ASLI DAN ALAM SEKITAR 5. ) KETUA PENGARAH TANAH DAN GALIAN 6. ) PENGARAH TANAH DAN GALIAN (WILAYAH PERSEKUTUAN) 7. ) PENDAFTAR HAKMILIK (WILAYAH PERSEKUTUAN)

12 November 2025

w-01a-668-11-2021 MYCOA

SEMANTAN ESTATE (1952) SDN. BHD. v 1. ) KERAJAAN MALAYSIA 2. ) PESURUHJAYA TANAH PERSEKUTUAN 3. ) MENTERI YANG BERTANGGUNGJAWAB BAGI TANAH DI WILAYAH PERSEKUTUAN 4. ) MENTERI SUMBER ASLI DAN ALAM SEKITAR 5. ) KETUA PENGARAH TANAH DAN GALIAN 6. ) PENGARAH TANAH DAN GALIAN (WILAYAH PERSEKUTUAN) 7. ) PENDAFTAR HAKMILIK (WILAYAH PERSEKUTUTUAN)

23 June 2025

Defendant (1)

wa-21ncvc-80-04-2021 MYHC

1. ) DATIN PADUKA DR. TAN YEE KEW 2. ) VIJAYA KUMARI A/P KANNIPAN 3. ) LEE CHUN TACK 4. ) RAZALI BIN ABU BAKAR 5. ) ASMUNI BIN NAFIAH 6. ) DEWI MURNI HARUN 7. ) VASANDA A/P VYTHILIGAM 8. ) MOHAMED NOORSYAFIQ BIN SHAMSUDIN 9. ) THULOSIMANY 10. ) SABRINA BINTI SAHUL HAMID 11. ) KALADEVI A/P RAMACHANTHIRAN 12. ) VELLAMMAL A/P VADAMALAY 13. ) RAJA NORSIDAH BT RAJA ABDUL JALIL 14. ) SITI NORWANA BINTI ZAKARIA 15. ) NUR AFIQAH BINIL MOHTAR APANDI 16. ) TAMIL SELVI A/P SUBRAMANIAM 17. ) MUNIAMAH A/P...

3 November 2025