M

Mary Lim Thiam Suan

FCJ 64 cases

About FCJ Mary Lim Thiam Suan

Mary Lim Thiam Suan has been involved in 64 judgments in the MY Case Law database, spanning December 1899 to May 2024. These cases are from the Federal Court (59 cases), Court of Appeal (5 cases). Mary Lim Thiam Suan served as the delivering judge in 9 cases and as a panel member in 55.

Key areas of jurisprudence include The central issue in these 4 appeals concerns the interpretation and understanding of the Attorney General’s consent obtained under Section 9 of the Government Proceedings Act 1956 [Act 359]. (4 cases), Application of Rosliza and Indira Gandhi (2 cases), 1. Enforcement of the Adjudication Decision under the Construction Industry Payment and Adjudication Act 2012 (“CIPAA”) (2 cases). Mary Lim Thiam Suan holds the designation of Dato'.

64

Total Cases

9

Delivered

55

Sat On (Coram)

How many cases has Mary Lim Thiam Suan been involved in?

Mary Lim Thiam Suan has been involved in 64 published judgments from December 1899 to May 2024, serving as the delivering judge in 9 of them. Cases span the Federal Court (59 cases), Court of Appeal (5 cases).

What types of cases does Mary Lim Thiam Suan typically handle?

Based on 64 published judgments, Mary Lim Thiam Suan's most common case types include The central issue in these 4 appeals concerns the interpretation and understanding of the Attorney General’s consent obtained under Section 9 of the Government Proceedings Act 1956 [Act 359]. (4 cases) and Application of Rosliza and Indira Gandhi (2 cases).

Which court does Mary Lim Thiam Suan sit on?

Mary Lim Thiam Suan sits on the Federal Court (Mahkamah Persekutuan) and Court of Appeal (Mahkamah Rayuan), with 64 published judgments from December 1899 to May 2024 in the database.

Practice Areas

The central issue in these 4 appeals concerns the interpretation and understanding of the Attorney General’s consent obtained under Section 9 of the Government Proceedings Act 1956 Act 359. 4 Of the four appeals, three appeals arose from the judicial review proceedings JR proceedings while the fourth appeal arose from proceedings related to Originating Summons No: 24NCVC-1128-12/2014 OS 1128. We heard all four appeals together. After full consideration of the submissions, reasonings of the Courts below and the records of appeal, we unanimously allowed the appeals relating to the JR proceedings and dismissed the appeal relating to OS 1128. 4 Application of Rosliza and Indira Gandhi 2 There are three appeals before us, two by Lembaga Lebuhraya Malaysia LLM and the third is by MMC Tepat Teknik Sdn Bhd MMC Tepat Teknik. All three appeals arise out of the compulsory acquisition of lands belonging to MMC Tepat Teknik under the Land Acquisition Act 1960 Act 486. After full consideration of the issues, we unanimously allowed the appeals by LLM and dismissed the appeal by MMC Tepat Teknik. 2 Breach of contract 2 1. Enforcement of the Adjudication Decision under the Construction Industry Payment and Adjudication Act 2012 (“CIPAA”) 2 2. Whether the strict rules of pleadings, as applicable in civil claims before the Malaysian Courts, apply in adjudicating proceedings under the Construction Industry Payment and Adjudication Act 2012? 2 3. Whether an adjudicator is prohibited from referring to a specific clause in a construction contract in allowing the claim when the said clause was not specifically stated in the Payment Claim and Adjudicating Claim by the claiming party? 2

Cases Delivered (9)

02f-60-10-2023a MYFC

1. ) GOLDEN STAR 2. ) Ding Toh Biew 3. ) Ding Toh Gien 4. ) Ding Toh Lei v 1. ) LING PEEK HOE 2. ) LING BOON HUAT

01f-3-02-2023p MYFC

1. ) FIVE STAR HERITAGE SDN BHD 2. ) XXXX 3. ) Maung Shwe Winn Sebagai Naib Pengerusi kepada Penang Burmese Society v Jabatan Peguam Negara

11 September 2023

02f-6-02-2023p MYFC

1. ) FIVE STAR HERITAGE SDN BHD 2. ) XXXX v 1. ) XXXX 2. ) Ho Choon Teik

11 September 2023

02f-7-02-2023p MYFC

1. ) FIVE STAR HERITAGE SDN BHD 2. ) XXXX 3. ) Maung Shwe Winn Sebagai Naib Pengerusi kepada Penang Burmese Society v XXXX

11 September 2023

02f-8-02-2023p MYFC

1. ) FIVE STAR HERITAGE SDN BHD 2. ) XXXX 3. ) Maung Shwe Winn Sebagai Naib Pengerusi kepada Penang Burmese Society v XXXX

11 September 2023

05hc-2-01-2023s MYFC

Peter Chang Nyuk Ming v 1. ) Pendakwa Raya [TIMBALAN MENTERI DALAM NEGERI, MALAYSIA] 2. ) MEOR AZIZI SAPAWI BIN AHMAD SEPUAN 3. ) Penguasa Kanan 4. ) Pendakwa Raya [Ketua Polis Negara]

a-02ncca-1508-08-2019 MYCOA

LITAR SISTEM ADILKAP SDN BHD (COMPANIES NO.: A-02(NCC)(A)-1508-08/2019 v 1. LEE TEAK HOCK (NO. K/P: 550907-08-5441) 2. LEE SOON HONG (NO. K/P: 810124-08-5785)

468-03-2019 MYCOA

DHARSHINI A/P GANESON (NO KP:580915-04-5068) v DORAISINGAM A/L THAMBYRAJAH (NO KP:560523-08-5863)

a-02imncvc-488-03-2019-didengar-bersama-a-02imncvc-521-03-2019 MYCOA

TENAGA NASIONAL BERHAD (NO. SYARIKAT: 200866-W) v 1. MY SEVEN VACATION SDN. BHD. (NO. SYARIKAT: 876333-K) 2. SECRET GARDEN HOTEL (NO. SYARIKAT :IP0324753-A)

31 December 1899

Coram (55)

01f-18-06-2023b MYFC

Dahlia Dhaima Binti Abdullah v MAJLIS AGAMA ISLAM SELANGOR (MAIS)

01f-19-06-2023b MYFC

Dahlia Dhaima Binti Abdullah v Kerajaan Negeri Selangor

02f-12-02-2023b MYFC

Siow Ching Yee v COLUMBIA ASIA SDN BHD AMICUS CURIE 1. ) Persatuan Hospital Swasta Malaysia (Association of Private Hospitals of Malaysia) 2. ) Persatuan Pengguna Pulau Pinang (Consumers Association of Penang (CAP)

22 February 2024

bka-2-05-2022d MYFC

1. ) NIK ELIN ZURINA BINTI NIK ABDUL RASHID 2. ) TENGKU YASMIN NASTASHA BINTI TENGKU ABDUL RAHMAN v Kerajaan Negeri Kelantan PEGUAM PEMERHATI 1. ) BADAN PEGUAM MALAYSIA [Fahri, Azzat & Co][S C Chua, Shaliza & Partners][Faiez & Co] 2. ) PERSATUAN PEGUAM-PEGUAM MUSLIM MALAYSIA 3. ) BADAN PEGUAM SYARIE WILAYAH PERSEKUTUAN 4. ) MAJLIS AGAMA ISLAM DAN ISTIADAT MELAYU PERLIS 5. ) PERSATUAN PEGUAM SYARIE MALAYSIA (PGSM) 6. ) MAJLIS AGAMA ISLAM NEGERI SEMBILAN (MAINS) 7. ) MAJLIS UGAMA ISLAM SABAH (M...

8 February 2024

02f-3-01-2023p MYFC

ANAS CONSTRUCTION SDN BHD v JKP SDN BHD

02f-4-01-2023p MYFC

ANAS CONSTRUCTION SDN BHD v JKP SDN BHD

05l-153-08-2022w MYFC

1. ) JJ Power Groups Enterprise 2. ) JJ Global Network Holdings Berhad 3. ) JJ Global Network 4. ) Utopia Entertainment Sdn Bhd 5. ) PCP Global Tech Sdn Bhd 6. ) L&L Property Ventures Sdn Bhd 7. ) JJ Global Recipe Sdn Bhd 8. ) Penang Old Wong Sdn Bhd 9. ) JTOM International Sdn Bhd 10. ) Hansard Group Sdn Bhd 11. ) Job Cafe Sdn Bhd 12. ) Babablue Sdn Bhd 13. ) JJ Global Creative Enterprise 14. ) Golden Pheonix Restaurant 15. ) Team V Team Sdn Bhd 16. ) Lee Choong Sen 17. ) Tan Kai Lee 18. ) L...

02i-48-08-2023n MYFC

ROBINDER SINGH JAJ A/L BIJIR SINGH v JASMINDER KAUR A/P BHAJAN SINGH AMICUS CURIE Bar Malaysia

05l-68-04-2022a MYFC

Pendakwa Raya [Timbalan Pendakwa Raya (TPR), Jabatan Peguam Negara] v Sanderasegaran A/l Nithenanham

28 November 2023

01f-46-11-2022b MYFC

Tegas Sejati Sdn Bhd v 1. ) Pentadbir Tanah Daerah Hulu Langat 2. ) Lembaga Lebuhraya Malaysia

22 October 2023

01f-5-02-2023t MYFC

15 October 2023

01i-18-05-2022w MYFC

MOHD NAJIB BIN HJ ABD RAZAK v Kerajaan Malaysia AMICUS CURIE BAR MALAYSIA

15 October 2023

01f-1-01-2022q MYFC

1. ) YONG ING KAI 2. ) HII LEH NGIICK @ HII YAING SING v SUPERINTENDENT OF LANDS AND SURVEYS, KUCHING DIVISION

02i-31-04-2023w MYFC

FIMBANK PLC v PEMILIK DAN/ATAU PENCARTER DEMIS KAPAL ATAU VESEL NIKA

01f-6-03-2022b MYFC

SARMIINA SDN BHD v 1. ) Gerry Ho 2. ) Ahmad Shukri Bin Zolkiflee 3. ) Nur Amin Binti Abdullah 4. ) Pengarah Kastam Negeri Johor 5. ) Ketua Pengarah Kastam Malaysia 6. ) Kerajaan Malaysia

02f-45-05-2022w MYFC

GENISYS INTEGRATED ENGINEERS PTE LTD v 1. ) UEM GENISYS SDN BHD (Dalam Likuidasi) 2. ) ONN KIEN HOE (disaman dalam kapasiti sebagai seorang pelikuidasi) 3. ) MOK YUEN LOK (disaman dalam kapasiti sebagai seorang pelikuidasi)

02f-73-09-2019p MYFC

THAMEEZ NISHA HASSEEM(sebagai Pentadbir Harta Pusaka Bee Fathima) v MALAYAN ALLIED BANK BERHAD

27 February 2023

02f-59-10-2021w MYFC

PEMBINAAN SPK SDN.BHD v 1. ) CONAIRE ENGINEERING SDN BHD L.L.C 2. ) BINA PURI HOLDINGS BHD

22 February 2023

02f-82-10-2019b MYFC

XXXX v TAN YING

17 January 2023

01f-19-05-2022b MYFC

Lembaga Lebuhraya Malaysia v 1. ) PENTADBIR TANAH DAERAH KLANG 2. ) MMC TEPAT TEKNIK SDN BHD

11 January 2023

01f-20-05-2022b MYFC

LEMBAGA LEBUHRAYA MALAYSIA v 1. ) PENTADBIR TANAH DAERAH KLANG 2. ) MMC TEPAT TEKNIK SDN BHD

11 January 2023

01f-8-03-2020b MYFC

MMC TEPAT TEKNIK SDN BHD v 1. ) PENTADBIR TANAH DAERAH KLANG 2. ) Lembaga Lebuhraya Malaysia

11 January 2023

01i-21-05-2022d MYFC

ABDUL LATIFF BIN PUTEH & 347 YANG LAIN v 1. ) Pentadbir Tanah Jajahan Pasir Mas 2. ) Kerajaan Negeri Kelantan

27 September 2022

01f-5-02-2022w MYFC

XXXX v Mahkamah Tentera Divisyen Keempat Infantri Malaysia

19 September 2022

05l-289-12-2021w MYFC

Dato' Sri Mohd Najib bin Hj Abd Razak v Pendakwa Raya [Pendakwa Raya]

01f-9-07-2021b MYFC

PEMUNGUT DUTI SETEM v LEE KOY ENG

05l-101-09-2020c MYFC

Tetuan Wan Shahrizal, Hari & Co v Pendakwa Raya [Jabatan Peguam Negara]

02f-63-10-2021p MYFC

XXXX v 1. ) LEE KIM NOOR 2. ) TETUAN KN LEE & ASSOCIATES

01f-32-11-2020d MYFC

DAE HANGURU INFRA SDN BHD v BALDAH TOYYIBAH (PRASARANA) KELANTAN SDN BHD

01f-33-11-2020d MYFC

DAE HANGURU INFRA SDN BHD v Perbadanan Menteri Besar Kelantan (PMBK)

01i-5-03-2020m MYFC

Tenaga Nasional Berhad v 1. Spicon Products Sdn. Bhd. 2. Pentadbir Tanah Alor Gajah

05m-10-01-2020b MYFC

Sathya A/l Vello v Pendakwa Raya [Pendakwa Raya]

7 February 2022

05hc-97-05-2021a MYFC

SUGENTHIRAN A/L PARAMASIVAM v 1. ) TIMBALAN MENTERI DALAM NEGERI MALAYSIA 2. ) PENGERUSI LEMBAGA PENASIHAT,JABATAN PERDANA MENTERI 3. ) PENGARAH, PUSAT PEMULIHAN AKHLAK, MACHANG KELANTAN 4. ) SARAVANAN A/L SUNDRA RAJAN

12 December 2021

01f-35-11-2020w MYFC

1.CCH 2.ADY v PENDAFTAR BESAR BAGI KELAHIRAN DAN KEMATIAN, MALAYSIA

18 November 2021

05l-23-02-2020b MYFC

01f-1-01-2019w MYFC

LEOW FOOK KEONG (L) v PENDAFTAR BESAR BAGI KELAHIRAN DAN KEMATIAN MALAYSIA, JABATAN PENDAFTARAN NEGARA, MALAYSIA & 1 LAGI

29 September 2021

no-06rs-1-03-2019w MYFC

Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim v 1. Kerajaan Malaysia 2. Majlis Keselamatan Negara

08rs-12-09-2019w MYFC

SEE TEOW KOON v 1. ) KIAN JOO CAN FACTORY BERHAD 2. ) KIAN JOO PACKAGING SDN BHD 3. ) KJ CAN (SELANGOR) SDN BHD

01i-34-10-2019w MYFC

1.CTEB 2.CWB v 1.Ketua Pengarah Pendaftaran Negara, Malaysia 2.Ketua Setiausaha, Kementerian Dalam Negeri 3.Kerajaan Malaysia

01f-24-08-2019j MYFC

PENTADBIR TANAH DAERAH JOHOR v NUSANTARA DAYA SDN BHD

05m-226-10-2019p MYFC

ROSLI BIN YUSOF v PENDAKWA RAYA

02f-33-07-2020b MYFC

AMBANK (M) BERHAD v AIM EDITION SDN BHD

01f-5-02-2017b-didengar-bersama-02f-8-02-2017b MYFC

1. ) 1. See Leong Chye @ Sze Leong Chye 2. See Ewe Lin 2. ) United Overseas Bank (Malaysia) Berhad v 1. ) United Overseas Bank (Malaysia) Berhad 2. ) 1. Kum Hoi Engineering Industries Sdn Bhd 2. Heveaplast Marketing Sdn. Bhd.

02f-4-01-2018 MYFC

CRYSTAL CROWN HOTEL & RESORT SDN BHD (CRYSTAL CROWN HOTEL PETALING JAYA) v KESATUAN KEBANGSAAN PEKERJA-PEKERJA HOTEL, BAR & RESTORAN SEMENANJUNG MALAYSIA

02i-35-04-2019w MYFC

1. GOH TENG WHOO 2. TAN HWA CHENG v AMPLE OBJECTIVES SDN. BHD.

02i-25-03-2020w MYFC

LIM LIP ENG v Ong Ka Chuan

01f-2-01-2020b MYFC

ROSLIZA BINTI IBRAHIM v 1. KERAJAAN NEGERI SELANGOR 2. MAJLIS AGAMA ISLAM SELANGOR

4 February 2021

01f-29-10-2019w-heard-together-with-01f-30-10-2019w-01i-40-12-2019m-01f-41-12-2019m-01f-42-12-2019m-01f-4-02-2020w-01f-31-10-2020w MYFC

1. ) PJD REGENCY SDN BHD 2. ) ONG SEE CHEN 3. ) ONG SEE SIEW 4. ) ONG SEE PING 5. ) SRI DAMANSARA SDN BHD v 1. ) 1.TRIBUNAL TUNTUTAN PEMBELI RUMAH 2.NG CHEE KUAN 2. ) 1.TRIBUNAL TUNTUTAN PEMBELI RUMAH 2.WONG KIEN CHOON 3. ) GJH AVENUE SDN BHD 4. ) 1.TRIBUNAL TUNTUTAN PEMBELI RUMAH 2.THONG CHEE WEI 3.TEOH SHEH WEE 5. ) 1.VOON KUAN CHIEN 2.TRIBUNAL TUNTUTAN PEMBELI RUMAH

18 January 2021

01f-5-03-2019w MYFC

MARIA CHIN ABDULLAH v 1.KETUA PENGARAH IMIGRESEN 2.MENTERI DALAM NEGERI

01f-27-09-2019b MYFC

MAJLIS DAERAH HULU SELANGOR v UNITED PLANTATIONS BERHAD (Company No.: 240-A)

3 November 2020

08rs-1-03-2020w MYFC

Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim v 1. ) Government of Malaysia 2. ) The National Security Council

9 September 2020

05m-56-02-2019j-didengar-bersama-05m-205-09-2018w-05m-206-09-2018w-05lb-207-09-2018w MYFC

1. ) ABDULLAH BIN ATAN 2. ) MOHAMMAD REZA GHAEM PANAH NEZAMALI 3. ) HASSAN JAVADIPIROUZ AVAZALI 4. ) PUBLIC PROSECUTOR v 1. ) PUBLIC PROSECUTOR 2. ) MAHMOOD YARY MOHAMMAD (PASSPORT NO. H 20682101S)

02-33-04-2017w MYFC

SITHRADEVI A/P NAGALINGAM v 1. MASDAR BIN DARMAN 2. SAMSUDIN BIN HAJI DARMAN PENCELAH MAJLIS PEGUAM MALAYSIA

a-02-ncvcw-689-03-2018 MYCOA

SRITHARAN NAIDU A/L SUNDARA RAJOO v DATO' DR. GENGATHARAN @ JEGANATHAN A/L VENKATESAN & 1 LAGI

a-02ncvcw-1974-10-2016 MYCOA

MALAYAN BANKING BERHAD v SYED AHMAD SAFAR BIN SYED KECHIK