1. ) NAZLAN BIN BAHARUDIN 2. ) IZYAN LIYANA BINTI AZHAR (NO. K/P: 870703-56-5112) Dan MUHAMMAD AFIQ BIN AZHAR (NO. K/P: 900311-14-6159) [Pentadbir harta pusaka AZHAR BIN AHMAT (NO. K/P: 650904-07-5115), si mati yang telah meninggal dunia pada 17hb Januari, 2023] 3. ) TAN TOH NGUANG 4. ) DATIN RUPAWAN BINTI MOHD SHARIF 5. ) NIK MOHD ZAIDI BIN NIK MOHD ZAIN 6. ) AKIRA MORIWAKI 7. ) NOORHASYIMAWATI BINTI JALALUDIN Sebagai Pentadbir Harta Pusaka AHMAD AIDEI BIN JALALUDDIN, simati 8. ) YUSOFF BIN ...

wa-22ncvc-535-09-2022 High Court (Mahkamah Tinggi) 19 March 2025 • WA-22NCvC-535-09/2022

Catchwords

Beneficial ownership and proprietary rights of purchasers in winding-up context. This case concerns the plaintiffs’ claim for beneficial ownership of their respective units in the “10 Semantan” development and the right to receive copies of strata titles in the context of the defendant company’s liquidation. The Court found that the plaintiffs had entered into valid sale and purchase agreements, paid the full purchase price and taken vacant possession. The Court held that official receipts were not the only valid proof of payment. Injunctive relief was granted to restrain the liquidators from disposing of the units. The judgment affirms that beneficial ownership may be proven through circumstantial and documentary evidence.

Practice Areas

Beneficial ownership and proprietary rights of purchasers in winding-up context. This case concerns the plaintiffs’ claim for beneficial ownership of their respective units in the “10 Semantan” development and the right to receive copies of strata titles in the context of the defendant company’s liquidation. The Court found that the plaintiffs had entered into valid sale and purchase agreements, paid the full purchase price and taken vacant possession. The Court held that official receipts were not the only valid proof of payment. Injunctive relief was granted to restrain the liquidators from disposing of the units. The judgment affirms that beneficial ownership may be proven through circumstantial and documentary evidence.

Judges (1)

Ahmad Shahrir b. Mohd Salleh Delivered

Parties (18)

MID QUANTUM Sdn Bhd. (dahulu dikenali sebagai Nandex Development Sdn Bhd.) (dalam Penggulungan) Defendant Akira Moriwaki Plaintiff Alizah binti Ali Plaintiff Datin Rupawan binti Mohd Sharif Plaintiff Indarjit Kaur Muker a/p Lall Singh Plaintiff Inderjit Singh a/l Saudagar Singh Plaintiff Izyan Liyana binti Azhar Dan Muhammad Afiq bin Azhar Plaintiff Low Pei Feng Plaintiff Mun Weng Sum Plaintiff Nazlan bin Baharudin Plaintiff Nik Mohd Zaidi bin Nik Mohd Zain Plaintiff Noorhasyimawati binti Jalaludin Sebagai Pentadbir Harta Pusaka Ahmad Aidei bin Jalaluddin, Simati Plaintiff Rubiah binti A Bakar Plaintiff Sarahatul Bahiah binti Yusoff Plaintiff Shimatul Aida binti Yusoff Plaintiff Taib bin Ayob Plaintiff Tan Toh Nguang Plaintiff Yusoff bin Saad Plaintiff

Case Significance

1. ) NAZLAN BIN BAHARUDIN 2. ) IZYAN LIYANA BINTI AZHAR (NO. K/P: 870703-56-5... is a High Court (Mahkamah Tinggi) decision dated March 19, 2025 (citation: wa-22ncvc-535-09-2022). The case was decided by Ahmad Shahrir b. Mohd Salleh.

What was the outcome of 1. ) NAZLAN BIN BAHARUDIN 2. ) IZYAN LIYANA BINTI AZHAR (NO. K/P: 870703-56-5...?

1. ) NAZLAN BIN BAHARUDIN 2. ) IZYAN LIYANA BINTI AZHAR (NO. K/P: 870703-56-5... is a High Court decision dated March 19, 2025. The case was heard by Ahmad Shahrir b. Mohd Salleh. See the full judgment for details.