S

Seri Zulkefli bin Ahmad Makinudin

FCJ 24 cases

About FCJ Seri Zulkefli bin Ahmad Makinudin

Seri Zulkefli bin Ahmad Makinudin has 24 reported Malaysia decisions (2017–2019). These were decided across MYFC (24). By subject matter, the largest shares are Constitutional Law (4), Administrative Law (3) and Bankruptcy & Insolvency (2). Of these, 19 as the delivering judge and 5 sitting on the coram.

On the judicial record

A record of apex-level reasoning on the law of deposits and forfeiture, contract under the Contracts Act 1950, the indefeasibility of a charge under the National Land Code, and bankruptcy, settling questions that bind the courts below.

Seri Zulkefli bin Ahmad Makinudin sits in the Federal Court, the apex court of Malaysia, and this collection gathers final appellate decisions across commercial, land and banking law. A significant commercial strand concerns the law of deposits and forfeiture on the termination of a contract, and the principles governing damages and the recovery of a paid deposit — questions of general importance to every commercial bargain. Contract appeals engage section 29 of the Contracts Act 1950, property under construction and progressive payment, and the termination of a sale-and-purchase agreement for an unpaid sum. Land law features through the sale and purchase of estate land and the conditional-contract requirements of section 214A of the National Land Code, and through the validity of a bank's registered charge where the chargor had obtained title by fraud and the question whether the charge was defeasible. Banking and insolvency appear through bankruptcy appeals on setting aside a bankruptcy notice and whether a judgment creditor may commence bankruptcy action after a judgment-debt summons order was complied with. Insurance is addressed where a policy was applied for and issued after the accident and whether it was void and unenforceable. Intellectual property features through an opposition to the registration of a trade mark and the appeal from the Registrar. Because the Federal Court sits in panels and its rulings bind the courts below, these decisions settle the correct construction of a statute or a common-law principle rather than merely resolving the dispute at hand. Private individuals are referred to by role; corporate, banking and statutory parties are named. A recurring concern is the certainty of commercial and property transactions — when a deposit may be forfeited, when a charge is indefeasible, when a bankruptcy action may proceed. The collection is a valuable record of apex-level reasoning on the law of contract, land and banking.

24
Total Cases
19
Delivered
5
Sat On (Coram)

How many cases has Seri Zulkefli bin Ahmad Makinudin decided?

Seri Zulkefli bin Ahmad Makinudin has 24 reported Malaysia decisions (2017–2019), 19 of them as the delivering judge.

Which courts does Seri Zulkefli bin Ahmad Makinudin sit in?

Seri Zulkefli bin Ahmad Makinudin sits in MYFC (24).

What commercial principle of general importance appears in Seri Zulkefli bin Ahmad Makinudin's docket?

The law of deposits and forfeiture on the termination of a contract, and the principles governing damages and the recovery of a paid deposit — questions that bear on the certainty of every commercial bargain and are settled at the apex level.

What land-law question does this collection address?

The validity of a bank's registered charge where the chargor had obtained title to the land by fraud, and whether the charge was therefore defeasible, together with the conditional-contract requirements for the sale of estate land under section 214A of the National Land Code.

Practice Areas

Cases Delivered (19)

02-105-10-2017w MYFC
CIMB Bank Berhad v 1. Anthony Lawrence Bourke 2. Alison Deborah Essex Bourke
16 December 2018
02f-64-09-2016w MYFC
Cubic Electronics Sdn. Bhd. (In Liquidation) v MARS Telecommunications Sdn. Bhd.
20 November 2018
civil-appeal-no-02f-45-05-2017b-didengar-bersama-civil-appeal-no-02f-46-05-2017b-civil-appeal-no-02f-59-06-2017b-civil-appeal-no-02f-60-06-2017b-civil-appeal-no-02f-65-06-2017b-civil-appeal-no-02f-61-06-2017b MYFC
GULA PERAK BERHAD; GULA PERAK BERHAD; AMBANK(M) BERHAD; AMBANK(M) BERHAD; FAITHMONT ESTATE SDN BHD; FAITHMONTH ESTATE SDN BHD; FAITHMONT ESTATE SDN BHD; v DATUK LIM SUE BENG; YAKIM TENGGARA SDN BHD; YAKIT TENGGARAN SDN BHD & 4 LAGI; DATUK LIM SUE BENG & 4 LAGI; YAKIN TENGGARA SDN BHD; DATUK LIM SUE BENG;YAKIN TENGGARA SDN BHD;
9 October 2018
no-02f-137-11-2017p MYFC
PACIFIC & ORIENT INSURANCE CO. BHD v HAMEED JAGUBAR BIN SYED AHMAD
23 September 2018
02f-76-07-2017-j MYFC
T. Sivam a/l Tharamalingam (Sebagai Wakil/Pentadbir kepada harta pusaka mendiang Nagamuthu a/l Periasamy) v Public Bank Berhad
16 May 2018
01f-9-04-2017w MYFC
MERCK KGaA v LENO MARKETING (M) SDN BHD PIHAK KETIGA REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS
6 May 2018
03f-2-04-2017w MYFC
1. ) MOHD KAMAL BIN OMAR 2. ) AZLIN AZRAI BIN LAN HAWARI 3. ) SIM KOK BENG v UNITED OVERSEAS BANK (MALAYSIA) BHD.
2 May 2018
03f-2-04-2017w-03f-3-01-2017w-03f-4-01-2017w MYFC
1. ) Mohd Kamal bin Omar 2. ) Azlin Azrai bin Lan Hawari 3. ) Sim Kok Beng v United Overseas Bank (Malaysia) Bhd.
2 May 2018
no-01f-21-09-2014w MYFC
1. PENGUSAHA, TEMPAT TAHANAN PERLINDUNGAN KAMUNTING, TAIPING 2. TIMBALAN MENTERI DALAM NEGERI 3. KERAJAAN MALAYSIA v BADRUL ZAMAN BIN P.S. MD ZAKARIAH
4 April 2018
01f-17-06-2016-a-01f-18-06-2016-a MYFC
Indira Gandhi a/p Mutho Indira Gandhi a/p Mutho Indira Gandhi a/p Mutho v 1. Pengarah Jabatan Agama Islam Perak 2. Pendaftar Mualaf 3. Kerajaan Negeri Perak 1. Kementerian Pelajaran Malaysia 2. Kerajaan Malaysia Pathmanathan a/l Krishnan PIHAK KETIGA Majls Peguam Malaysia Parti Gerakan Rakyat Malaysia Association of Women Lawyers
28 January 2018
01f-17-06-2016-a-01f-18-06-2016-a-01f-19-06-2016-a MYFC
Indira Gandhi a/p Mutho Indira Gandhi a/p Mutho Indira Gandhi a/p Mutho v 1. Pengarah Jabatan Agama Islam Perak 2. Pendaftar Mualaf 3. Kerajaan Negeri Perak 1. Kementerian Pelajaran Malaysia 2. Kerajaan Malaysia Patmanathan a/l Krishnan PIHAK KETIGA Majlis Peguam Malaysia Parti Gerakan Rakyat Malaysia. Association of Women Lawyers.
28 January 2018
02f-65-09-2016j MYFC
KANG HAI HOLDINGS SDN BHD & 1 LAGI v LEE LAI BAN
18 December 2017
01f-22-10-2014q MYFC
1. ) Keruntum Sdn Bhd 2. ) Datuk Seri Gopal Sri Ram, Colin Lau & David Yu v 1. ) 1. The Director of Forest 2. The Minister of Resources Planning 3. The Government of the State of Sarawak 2. ) Datuk Foong Joo Chung & Lonie Anak Pindda
6 December 2017
02-19-04-2016 MYFC
1. Far East Holdings Bhd 2. Kampong Aur Oil Palm Sdn Bhd ... Appellants v Majlis Ugama Islam dan Adat Resam Melayu Pahang ... Respondent
14 November 2017
02f-45-07-2016w MYFC
RINOTA CONSTRUCTION SDN BHD … Appellant/ Petitioner v 1. MASCON RINOTA SDN BHD … Respondents 2. MASCON SDN BHD 3. OLYMPIA INDUSTRIES BHD 4. DATO’ YAP YONG SEONG 5. YAP WEE KEAAT 6. MASCON CONSTRUCTION SDN BHD
8 November 2017
03f-1-01-2017d MYFC
Kempadang Bersatu Sdn Bhd v Perkayuan O.K.S. No. 2 Sdn Bhd
6 November 2017
02f-11-02-2017-w MYFC
VIEW ESTEEM SDN BHD … APPELLANT v BINA PURI HOLDINGS BERHAD … RESPONDENT
5 November 2017
02f-16-03-2017-k MYFC
LOW CHI YONG (Berniaga sebagai Reynox Fertichem Industries) …APPELLANT v 1. LOW CHI HONG 2. REYNOX SDN BHD (No. Syarikat: 796218-T) …RESPONDENTS
5 October 2017
02-66-10-2015k MYFC
USIMA SDN BHD (No. Syarikat : 206761-H) … APPELLANT v LEE HOR FONG (berniaga di bawah nama dan gaya PEMBINAAN LH FONG) … RESPONDENT
5 September 2017

Coram (5)