1. ) Kerajaan Malaysia 2. ) PERDANA MENTERI MALAYSIA 3. ) MENTERI KANAN PERTAHANAN MALAYSIA 4. ) MAJLIS ANGKATAN TENTERA v 1. ) MIOR ROSLI BIN MIOR MD JAAFAR 2. ) BASIR BIN AB. RAHMAN 3. ) ANUAR BIN ABDUL HAMID 4. ) YAAKOB BIN MD LAZID 5. ) MOHD NAWI BIN HUSIN 6. ) SHUIB BIN TAIB 7. ) ABDUL HALIM BIN LONG 8. ) ZAMZALI BIN SEMAN 9. ) SHAHAWARUDIN BIN ISMAIL 10. ) BATUMALAI @ PURUSOTHAMAN A/L BATUMALAI 11. ) ARUJUNAN A/L WAIRAMUTHU 12. ) SHARUDDIN BIN ISMAIL 13. ) ISHAK BIN YACCOB 14. ) ZAINAL ...
w-01ncvca-109-02-2024 Court of Appeal (Mahkamah Rayuan) 3 June 2025 • W-01(NCvC)(A)-109-02/2024 • 3 min read
Catchwords
Civil appeal - Pensionable members of the Malaysian Armed Forces - Article 132, 137 and 147 of the Federal Constitution - Armed Forces Act 1972 - Pensions Regulations 1982 - Whether any pension adjustment had been carried out from 2002 to 2013 by the Defendants - Whether there was unequal treatment by the Defendants in the Plaintiff’s pensions adjustments - Appeal by the Defendants is allowed. Supporting Judgment Article 8(1) FC – Equality – Premised on the above Federal Court cases, whether an executive policy, action or decision (Executive Policy/Action/Decision) has breached Article 8(1) FC- whether an executive policy, action or decision Executive Policy/Action/Decision had provided for the same treatment for all persons in a particular class - whether an executive policy, action or decision Executive Policy/Action/Decision has not discriminated against any person and there is therefore no contravention of the equality provision in Article 8(1)- Executive Policy/Action/Decision had discriminated against a particular or group of persons-whether there exists a nexus between the Reasonable classification and the object of the Executive Policy/Action/Decision-is the Reasonable Classification proportionate to the Object
Practice Areas
Parties (54)
Kerajaan Malaysia Appellant MENTERI KANAN PERTAHANAN MALAYSIA Appellant Majlis Angkatan Tentera Appellant PERDANA MENTERI MALAYSIA Appellant Abd Jalil bin Ramli Respondent Abd Razak bin Saad Respondent Abdul Halim bin Long Respondent Adnan bin Yahya Respondent Ahmad Zahid bin Mat Som Respondent Aklasmia bin Ismail Ali Respondent Aman Shah bin Mohd Ali Respondent Aminuddin bin Mohd Hussin Respondent Amran bin Ibrahim Respondent Anuar bin Abdul Hamid Respondent Arujunan a/l Wairamuthu Respondent Basir bin Ab. Rahman Respondent Batumalai @ Purusothaman a/l Batumalai Respondent Hamzah bin Husin Respondent Ishak bin Mohd Lazid Respondent Ishak bin Yaccob Respondent Ismail bin Nazalan Respondent Ismail bin Sulaiman Respondent Jaafar bin Arshad Respondent Jamaludin bin Hasan Respondent Kamarudin bin Osman Respondent Loo Woi Chin Respondent Md Razi bin Saafee @ Shafee Respondent Md Yusop bin Othman Respondent Md. Yusof bin Saad Respondent Mior Rosli bin Mior Md Jaafar Respondent Moganandass a/l Sakarapani Respondent Mohamad Zafri bin Abu Bakar Respondent Mohamad bin Idris Respondent Mohd Aris bin Saad Respondent Mohd Ishak bin Nordin Respondent Mohd Nawi bin Husin Respondent Mohd Shafir bin Kasim Respondent Mustafa bin Manas Respondent Omar Shahrim bin Mohd Khiruddin Respondent Razalai bin Tahir Respondent Sahadan bin Omar Respondent Salleh bin Baharom Respondent Samsuddin bin Hamat Respondent Shaharum bin Abdul Hamid Respondent Shahawarudin bin Ismail Respondent Sharuddin bin Ismail Respondent Shuib bin Taib Respondent Tahir bin Jusoh Respondent Taufek bin Mohamod Respondent Taufek bin Mohd Radzi Respondent Yaakob bin Md Lazid Respondent Zainal Abidin bin Ahmad Respondent Zakaria bin Sedek Respondent Zamzali bin Seman Respondent
Case Significance
1. ) Kerajaan Malaysia 2. ) PERDANA MENTERI MALAYSIA 3. ) MENTERI KANAN PERTA... is a Court of Appeal (Mahkamah Rayuan) decision dated June 3, 2025 (citation: w-01ncvca-109-02-2024). The panel comprised Hashim bin Hamzah, Ismail bin Brahim and Wong Kian Kheong, with Hashim bin Hamzah delivering the judgment.
What was the outcome of 1. ) Kerajaan Malaysia 2. ) PERDANA MENTERI MALAYSIA 3. ) MENTERI KANAN PERTA...?
1. ) Kerajaan Malaysia 2. ) PERDANA MENTERI MALAYSIA 3. ) MENTERI KANAN PERTA... is a Court of Appeal decision dated June 3, 2025. The case was heard by Hashim bin Hamzah. See the full judgment for details.