1. ) Pan Fei Yoong 2. ) Pang Fooi Keong 3. ) Phang Yit Fui [Menuntut Sebagai Pentadbir Harta Pusaka Phang Foi Sing] 4. ) Pang Fui Choo v Tenaga Nasional Berhad

wa-12bncvc-168-12-2023 High Court (Mahkamah Tinggi) 18 February 2025 • WA-12BNCvC-168-12/2023

Catchwords

This appeal was dismissed. Costs of RM10,000 were awarded to the Respondent. This Court ruled that this case was not an appropriate one for appellate intervention. The Appellants had failed to show that the Sessions Court did not accord sufficient judicial appreciation of the facts and evidence of the case (refer to the Court of Appeal’s decision in Gan Yook Chin & Anor v Lee ing Chin & Ors [2004] 4 CLJ 309). The Appellant had not demonstrated that the ‘plainly wrong’ test was fulfilled to disturb the Sessions Court’s finding (see the Federal Court’s decision in Ng Hooi Kui v Wendy Tan Lee Peng, Administrator of the Estate of Tan Ewe Kwang, Deceased & Ors [2020] 10 CLJ 1).

Practice Areas

This appeal was dismissed. Costs of RM10,000 were awarded to the Respondent. This Court ruled that this case was not an appropriate one for appellate intervention. The Appellants had failed to show that the Sessions Court did not accord sufficient judicial appreciation of the facts and evidence of the case (refer to the Court of Appeal’s decision in Gan Yook Chin & Anor v Lee ing Chin & Ors 2004 4 CLJ 309). The Appellant had not demonstrated that the ‘plainly wrong’ test was fulfilled to disturb the Sessions Court’s finding (see the Federal Court’s decision in Ng Hooi Kui v Wendy Tan Lee Peng, Administrator of the Estate of Tan Ewe Kwang, Deceased & Ors 2020 10 CLJ 1).

Judges (1)

Roz Mawar binti Rozain Delivered

Parties (5)

TENAGA NASIONAL BERHAD Respondent Pan Fei Yoong Appellant Pang Fooi Keong Appellant Pang Fui Choo Appellant Phang Yit Fui Appellant

Case Significance

1. ) Pan Fei Yoong 2. ) Pang Fooi Keong 3. ) Phang Yit Fui [Menuntut Sebagai ... is a High Court (Mahkamah Tinggi) decision dated February 18, 2025 (citation: wa-12bncvc-168-12-2023). The case was decided by Roz Mawar binti Rozain.

What was the outcome of 1. ) Pan Fei Yoong 2. ) Pang Fooi Keong 3. ) Phang Yit Fui [Menuntut Sebagai ...?

1. ) Pan Fei Yoong 2. ) Pang Fooi Keong 3. ) Phang Yit Fui [Menuntut Sebagai ... is a High Court decision dated February 18, 2025. The case was heard by Roz Mawar binti Rozain. See the full judgment for details.