PACIFIC & ORIENT INSURANCE CO. BHD v 1. ) Mohd Aminizam bin Zainal Abidin 2. ) Azura Binti Md Nor 3. ) Ahmad Mustaqim bin Md Nor

ba-12b-11-02-2023 High Court (Mahkamah Tinggi) 3 February 2025 • BA-12B-11-02/2023

Catchwords

Appeal after full trial – Road accident – Insurance company intervened – Counterclaim for insurance fraud - Whether Plaintiff has proved its intended case as pleaded - Res ipsa loquitur – Whether there was a collision - Whether it is due to 2nd Defendant’s negligence – Inconsistent testimonies – Contradict pleading - No objective evidence of collision - Credibility of corroborating witnesses - Appellate interference - Failure to properly evaluate the totality of the evidence

Practice Areas

Appeal after full trial

Judges (1)

Elaine Yap Chin Gaik Delivered

Parties (4)

Ahmad Mustaqim bin Md Nor Respondent Azura binti Md Nor Respondent Mohd Aminizam bin Zainal Abidin Respondent Pacific & Orient Insurance Co. Bhd Appellant

Case Significance

PACIFIC & ORIENT INSURANCE CO. BHD v 1. ) Mohd Aminizam bin Zainal Abidin 2. ... is a High Court (Mahkamah Tinggi) decision dated February 3, 2025 (citation: ba-12b-11-02-2023). The case was decided by Elaine Yap Chin Gaik.

What was the outcome of PACIFIC & ORIENT INSURANCE CO. BHD v 1. ) Mohd Aminizam bin Zainal Abidin 2. ...?

PACIFIC & ORIENT INSURANCE CO. BHD v 1. ) Mohd Aminizam bin Zainal Abidin 2. ... is a High Court decision dated February 3, 2025. The case was heard by Elaine Yap Chin Gaik. See the full judgment for details.